20-06-2006, 11:36 PM
New laws 'won't stop canned hunting'
Johannesburg, South Africa
South Africa's proposals to clamp down on "canned hunting", or the killing of captive animals, will be useless unless the laws are clear and properly enforced, an animal welfare group said on Monday.
"All the Bills and laws in the world will not stop the scourge of captive hunting, and the loopholes will be exploited," said Neil Greenwood, spokesperson for the Southern Africa chapter of the International Fund for Animal Welfare.
Greenwood was speaking as the deadline closed for public comment on government proposals to regulate captive hunting, which brings in about R25-billion a year in South Africa, drawing game hunters from Europe and the United States.
He said a major drawback is that the distance from which an animal can be killed and the dimensions of the hunting area are not spelt out.
"No minimum dimensions have been given, which then creates a situation that becomes subjective to interpretation about the specific measurement of the area in which an animal can be hunted and from what distance," he said.
Greenwood also said the proposed laws need to be implemented effectively.
"It's all very well to make suggestions, but we need to know how the government plans to enforce all of this," he said.
The proposals were unveiled by Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism Marthinus van Schalkwyk in May to bring in "integrity and best practices".
Citing examples where rhinos were killed with crossbows or bows and arrows, Greenwood added that hunting should be conducted along "fair chase" principles, pitting the hunter's wits against those of the animal.
South Africa has become one of the hunting world's greatest draws, attracting about 9 500 foreign hunters every year, the Professional Hunters' Association of South Africa estimated last year.
About 9 000 privately owned ranches employ about 70 000 people to cater to foreign hunters who come to hunt animals, including Africa's "Big Five" -- the lion, leopard, buffalo, elephant and rhino. -- Sapa-AFP
.....nu OGSÅ ejer af en 243win :-)
Favourite Quote: Vi løser ikke vore problemer ved at tænke på samme måde, som da vi skabte dem.....(Albert Einstein)
Johannesburg, South Africa
South Africa's proposals to clamp down on "canned hunting", or the killing of captive animals, will be useless unless the laws are clear and properly enforced, an animal welfare group said on Monday.
"All the Bills and laws in the world will not stop the scourge of captive hunting, and the loopholes will be exploited," said Neil Greenwood, spokesperson for the Southern Africa chapter of the International Fund for Animal Welfare.
Greenwood was speaking as the deadline closed for public comment on government proposals to regulate captive hunting, which brings in about R25-billion a year in South Africa, drawing game hunters from Europe and the United States.
He said a major drawback is that the distance from which an animal can be killed and the dimensions of the hunting area are not spelt out.
"No minimum dimensions have been given, which then creates a situation that becomes subjective to interpretation about the specific measurement of the area in which an animal can be hunted and from what distance," he said.
Greenwood also said the proposed laws need to be implemented effectively.
"It's all very well to make suggestions, but we need to know how the government plans to enforce all of this," he said.
The proposals were unveiled by Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism Marthinus van Schalkwyk in May to bring in "integrity and best practices".
Citing examples where rhinos were killed with crossbows or bows and arrows, Greenwood added that hunting should be conducted along "fair chase" principles, pitting the hunter's wits against those of the animal.
South Africa has become one of the hunting world's greatest draws, attracting about 9 500 foreign hunters every year, the Professional Hunters' Association of South Africa estimated last year.
About 9 000 privately owned ranches employ about 70 000 people to cater to foreign hunters who come to hunt animals, including Africa's "Big Five" -- the lion, leopard, buffalo, elephant and rhino. -- Sapa-AFP
.....nu OGSÅ ejer af en 243win :-)
Favourite Quote: Vi løser ikke vore problemer ved at tænke på samme måde, som da vi skabte dem.....(Albert Einstein)
.....ualmindelig velinformeret i forhold til min alder ... :-)
Favourite Quote: En humlebi ved ikke, at den ikke kan flyve......Gå ud på terrassen og vift med armene...hvis du letter må du være uvidende ;-)
Favourite Quote: En humlebi ved ikke, at den ikke kan flyve......Gå ud på terrassen og vift med armene...hvis du letter må du være uvidende ;-)